Everton: Lawyer predicts maximum size of 3rd points deduction in hearing on stadium payments
Everton face a maximum further points deduction of one point from their next hearing, Stefan Borson has predicted.
The lawyer and former Manchester City financial advisor reacted via Twitter on 8 April after the written reasons for the Toffees’ latest points deduction were released, where it emerged the two-point sanction that has been handed down may not be the final outcome of the second breach of spending rules.
The panel chose not to reach a decision on the ongoing dispute between Everton and the Premier League over £6.5m in interest payments relating to the new stadium development, which the league wants to include as a loss in the profit and sustainability calculations and the club insist shouldn’t be as it has been audited in the stadium accounts [Giulia Bould, 8 April].
As the next hearing can’t be heard before the end of the season any punishment will come next term, despite the Premier League changing the rules to an expedited process specifically to avoid that, and Borson doesn’t believe it can’t result in more than one more point off.
He wrote: “This second limb can’t be dealt with under the expedited process – so it means another *potential* point (surely not more) to be deducted in 24/25.”
Bramley Moore Dock stadium to cost Everton new points deduction?
In the context of what Sean Dyche and his side have had to operate under this season a single point being taken away might sound like a walk in the park.
But when Everton also face being in breach of PSR rules for a third-straight season it quite possibly wouldn’t be all that was lost next term.
Perhaps it is preferable for the stadium interest issue to be deferred if it means any punishment isn’t mounted on top of the eight already deducted this season, pending the Toffees’ second appeal, when the team has only just recorded its first win of 2024 in what looks increasingly like another nail-biting relegation fight.
But it is bemusing that after all the build up, and having the rules changed to ultimately punish Everton twice in one season, the commission could simply decide not to make a decision on an issue which has been a key part of the profit and sustainability arguments from the start, even if this one appears to have been broadly more sympathetic than the first.
And the fact that this again means there could be important developments relation to this season that don’t arrive until the following campaign has possibly stored up a new set of legal problems for everyone involved.
So what has already been a messy process that seems to have generated nothing but recriminations seems to be set to continue in the same vein, even if the material effect of a further punishment will perhaps be kept to a minimum.
In other Everton news, a politician has reacted furiously at the “agenda” being carried out against the club and its fans.
For more Everton news, follow us on Facebook or join our brand new WhatsApp Channel for instant updates to be sent straight to your phone.