Tim Sherwood in heated debate over Everton v Brentford controversy
Tim Sherwood and Karen Carney are on opposite sides of the red card incident from Everton v Brentford on Saturday.
The Toffees and the Bees played out a 0-0 draw at Goodison Park on 23 November with Brentford’s Christian Norgaard receiving his marching orders.
Sherwood believes that Chris Kavanagh was wrong to send him off while Carney states that he was merely applying the rules.
Speaking on Premier League Productions’ Weekend Wrap, Sherwood said (24 November, 9:52pm): “I don’t think it’s a red card. I really don’t. You have to go for the ball.”
Carney then responded: “The rules suggest that it’s a red card. I get that he had to go for the ball.”
Christian Norgaard deserved the red in the Everton v Brentford clash
The decision to send off Brentford’s Norgaard was justified due to the nature of his challenge on Pickford.
Upon reviewing the incident, it became clear that the Danish midfielder’s tackle was dangerously executed.
He attempted to win the ball but instead made contact with Pickford at knee height, using the studs of his boot.
This type of challenge, where a player goes in with high studs and fails to connect with the ball, is often deemed reckless and endangering the safety of an opponent.
Although there was no intent to harm, the laws of the game mandate that such actions, where there is a significant risk of injury due to the manner of the challenge, result in a red card.
The referee’s decision was upheld after further review, reflecting the game’s commitment to player safety over the original perception of the play as mere competitive action.
In other Everton news, Alan Myers has revealed if new court “issues” are now set to impact the club’s takeover.
For more Everton news, follow us on Facebook or join our brand new WhatsApp Channel for instant updates to be sent straight to your phone.