Everton show backwards thinking as deal to re-sign academy failure Isaac Price on the cards

Everton are showing their transfer idiocy once again as they are interested in signing former Finch Farm academy youngster Isaac Price.

The Toffees released the attacking midfielder at the end of his contract in 2023, as he then made his way to Belgium to sign for Standard Liege.

After showing some signs of potential, West Brom swooped in for Price in the 2025 winter window, where he’s enjoyed his time at The Hawthorns.

The 22-year-old has now made somewhat of a name for himself in the Championship, playing a big part in helping keep Albion in the second tier after relegation fears.

Almost three years after deeming him a Finch Farm failure, Everton now wants to re-sign Price in another transfer link that just truly baffles.

🚨 EVERTON TRANSFER HUB 🚨

Breaking news on active deals, incoming signings, Hill Dickinson Stadium departures, and Friedkin Group priorities.

The definitive source for EFC recruitment news

What has been said about Everton re-signing Isaac Price?

There have been suggestions to say that Everton still regret letting Price go for nothing, as the youngster has been performing for club and country in the last two seasons.

The Northern Irishman was always seen as a Finch Farm reject, as he only managed to make five senior appearances across two years before the Toffees disposed of him.

Club/NationTime spent at club/nationGamesGoalsAssists
Standard LiegeJune 2023 – January 20256312
West Bromwich AlbionJanuary 2025 – Present64104
Northern IrelandMarch 2023 – Present30101
Price since leaving Everton

As seen in the table above, Price has really taken off since signing for West Brom, and has especially excelled on the highest stage of them all, playing well for his country.

According to Express & Star on Monday, Everton are one of three interested Premier League clubs that would like to sign Price this summer.

Isaac Price's Everton career appearances.
Credit: Breaking Media

Crystal Palace and Fulham are said to be interested, but even the Toffees would outdo themselves if they put their foot to the pedal on this one and get it done.

There’s a good chance that the Baggies hold off for around £10million, which will truly feel like money flushed down the drain considering Everton once had him at the club.

What does this say about Everton’s transfer plans?

Price can play anywhere across the frontline, but mainly excels in central positions. He has a wide range of ways to score goals. He can score with both feet, with his head, and has an eye for goal from range.

That being said, the former Everton youth star would do well to knock Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall out of the team.

So unless David Moyes and Co. expect their key number 10 to depart Hill Dickinson this summer, then there’s only one reason why they may be in for Price.

That reason would be depth, something that the Blues desperately need.

However, it still wouldn’t take away from the fact that it would be a totally backwards transfer story for Everton.

Don’t Miss a Beat: Your Goodison News Insider Access

Updated 24/7 with expert analysis from the heart of Goodison Park.